“You own everything that happened to you. Tell your stories. If people wanted you to write warmly about them, they should have behaved better.” — Anne Lamott, Bird by Bird
How do you write about “villains,” meaning the bad actors or neglectful people in your non-fiction or memoir? A few years ago, former child-star Jennette McCurdy released the #1 NY Times Best-Seller, I’m Glad My Mom Died, a memoir documenting her mother’s controlling and abusive behavior. Over three million copies have sold, even though McCurdy wasn’t exactly a household name. On the surface, McCurdy’s book reflects the deep desire people have to talk about those who’ve hurt them. However, is there a difference between telling your story of your healing journey and trashing the villains involved?
If you have a hard or heavy story, writing can play a powerful role in your healing journey. Research points to many benefits of writing down our thoughts and stories. When people ask me whether they should write their story, my answer is always, “YES! Do it.” Putting down your experiences and your life journey, recording in black-and-white, is an incredibly meaningful human experience.
However, when it comes to publishing, hopeful authors should be mindful of how they write about others, especially those who hurt or neglected us. As a literary agent, it’s my job to help writers understand that publishers care about avoiding defamation or invasion-of-privacy issues. At the same time, I also like to help writers understand that how they write about others can either help or hurt the healing process.
Today’s post offers a literary agent’s perspective on how to set up your memoir or non-fiction project for successful pitching in the future. For those who still building up the courage to write your story, this first point is for you.
1. You have permission to write about what happened to you.
Hear me when I say that no one can or should stop you from writing your story if that’s what you feel led to do. Perhaps that’s the reason why you came across this post – you needed permission to write your story. Here it is: You have permission to write about what happened to you.
The harder question is when you should pursue publishing your story. There’s no hard and fast answer, but in my experience, no one has ever regretted waiting, but plenty of people have regretted publishing too soon. Take your time to heal and allow at least some perspective and growth to happen before you pitch to a literary agent. If you’re not sure if you’re ready, I’m sharing some practical questions at the end of this post.
2. Are you writing for validation, or are you building a case against someone else?
A well-known saying reminds us how important it is to have others witness our pain: “Grief requires a witness.”
When hard or heavy things happen to us, having others acknowledge our pain or grief is needed for us to move through the healing process. However, a book isn’t necessary to validate your pain and loss. Perhaps you needed to see today’s post for me to share the following: What happened to you was real, and your pain is real, too.
As a literary agent, I’ve seen plenty of instances where someone was hurt by a parent, a pastor, or a spouse, and writing out their story resulted in a manuscript that looked more like a hit piece than a book that captured a healing journey. Yes, you’re allowed to tell the truth about what happened to you, but is your book more about what happened to you or about how you changed and grew as a result?
How can you know if your book captures your healing journey or you’re putting too much emphasis on the people that hurt you?
- Question #1: Does your book share a series of events or do you take the reader on your healing journey?
- Question #2: Do you want readers to despise the bad actors in your stories as much as you do? Or can you write about those who hurt you from a perspective or through the lens of faith and forgiveness?
For sure, memoirs are always stronger when forgiveness has taken place, so that the facts can be written, but the judgments are left for the reader to make.
Here’s a helpful principle to keep in mind as you’re writing your hard or heavy story:
3. “Keep the Focus on You.”
I learned this popular slogan in a family member addiction support group that I began attending over a decade ago. A new author, I was also the spouse of someone struggling with alcohol addiction. I was thrust into a difficult situation I didn’t cause and couldn’t change. As a writer, I wasn’t sure how to talk about the sad and difficult things going on in our lives.
However, as I sat in that room with people I only knew by their first name, I learned how to write my story without tearing someone else down. The key: Learning to keep the focus on myself by writing about what the program refers to as my “experience, strength, and hope.”
Keeping the focus on ourselves keeps us in the center of the story versus giving more attention to those who hurt us.
Popular podcaster Dr. John Deloney popularized the saying, “Not by my hand, but in my lap,” meaning that there are things in life that we didn’t ask for, but we need to learn how to deal with them. In a similar quote, Chuck Swindoll is credited with saying, “Life is 10% of what happens to you and 90% of what you do with it.”
When writers focus their memoirs or self-help books on the bad behavior of others, they likely haven’t had enough time to explore their own transformation. Here are some questions that should be answered in your healing journey and reflected in your manuscript:
- If you had to pick 2-3 themes like hope, forgiveness, or courage to describe your journey, which themes are highlighted in your manuscript?
- What decisions did you make that changed your direction or life?
- Which beliefs about yourself or others changed? What do you believe now?
- Who came to help you, and how did they help you?
- What do you know about those abusive or neglectful people that you didn’t know at the time?
- How has forgiveness shaped your life now compared to before you forgave?
- How do you live differently now?
- What experience, strength, and hope have you gained as a result of what you went through?
As I close today’s conversation, I pray that those who needed permission to write their stories would receive it. If you needed someone to validate your experience of pain or loss, let me say again that I’m so sorry for what you’ve been through.
I hope today’s article can play a helpful, hopeful role in your healing journey.
JOIN THE CONVERSATION: Do you have any other advice for writers who are writing hard or heavy stories? How have you learned to write about the “villains” truthfully in your story without trashing them?

Capacity Counts More Than Math