I never intended to spend so much of my time ushering books into movies. Oh, I know that most authors pine to see their books turned into film. But I also know what an arduous journey it is. Thus rendering my enthusiasm lukewarm.
Knowing this is true of me, you may be surprised to learn that I’ve had a hand in the following:
- Three Christmases in a row Robin Jones Gunn’s Father Christmas movies set new records for viewership on Hallmark’s Movies and Mysteries channel. Each year the latest iteration of Father Christmas exceeded the viewership of the film released the year before.
- Robin had a novel from her Glenbrooke Series also turned into a film that was released on the Hallmark channel.
- A nonfiction narrative by one of my clients is being shopped even as I write this by an award-winning director whose exploration of the Tylenol murders was the #1 release on Netflix a few years ago.
- Another client’s novel series was all set for filming to begin the next day by Netflix when the TV series was nixed by an entirely new executive team with the words, “Who would want to watch that!?”
- Another project came to within a whisker of being put into production by Reese Witherspoon’s film company, Hello Sunshine.
- Three other novel series are being actively worked on by production companies to bring them to viewers.
So here’s a peek behind the scenes of turning books into movies. I’ve learned the following lessons:
Patience is Imperative
Just because interest is expressed in your work, don’t expect quick results.
My client with the lost Netflix deal signed a shopping agreement with a production company in 2013. All parties involved hoped shooting would begin on the TV series spring of 2019.
Another novel series has had a film option with a production company since 2017. Each year the producer inches forward in making the magic happen. A great script has been created, and key players are added to the team every year. It’s so-o-o-o close to happening!…But not yet.
The Father Christmas films began when I sent a copy of the novella Finding Father Christmas to a producer who worked regularly on Hallmark Christmas films. It took ten years to move from writing the novella to sending in that book to a movie being shot. But once the production team read the book, they were all in. And suddenly, Robin and I were on set.

Get Rich Quick?
Considering the long haul to even reach the point of a film being produced, both the author and the agent have to keep a big picture perspective on not only the timing of a movie but also seeing financial gain. The largest payments tend to come when actual shooting takes place. Waiting five years or more for the book to be turned into a movie isn’t exactly a get-rich-quick scheme.
Sometimes even when the book does reach the point of being made into a movie, the payout may not be what a writer would think. Depending on how the film is distributed (streaming is king, but a theatrical release first will add to the sum) or if a major actor is attached to the work, the author’s payoff varies wildly. Ultimately, the possibility of getting rich is very slim.
Holding It All Loosely
An author must be prepared to hold his creative efforts loosely when it comes to turning books into movies. Once a scriptwriter is unleashed on your book, it’s his imagination and intent that lead the way. Details an author would view sacrosanct must be released.
When Robin and I had our first conversation with the producers about changes to expect in the Finding Father Christmas story, our jaws dropped. The novella takes place in England, with the Father Christmas character and the setting playing a significant role in the story.
But in the film, the story was set to take place in Vermont.

And Santa Claus would be the Christmas character, not Father Christmas.
The Hallmark executive team decided to call the film Christmas in Maine. Fortunately, Robin was able to convince the Hallmark president that Finding Father Christmas made it much more notable among the league of Hallmark movies that exist.
After Robin and I found out the change in the setting and the disappearance of Father Christmas, we wondered why the producers had even bothered to option the novella.
Truth Shines Through
But eventually we came to see that the essence of the story was left in tact. The concepts of longing to belong, the search for identity, and the willingness to forgive survived to shine brightly when the film was done.

The scriptwriter, we noted, surgically removed all the faith elements. But the concepts of loving unconditionally, opening our hearts to others, and having the courage to ask hard questions were so embedded in the story that they remained through the script’s iterations.
But the author must accept that she is releasing her story wholeheartedly to be fashioned into a film that others envision based on the book.
Look for the Blessings
When Robin and I visited the set for the filming of Finding Father Christmas, we didn’t know what to expect. We were prepared to be viewed as in the way, while the crew rushed about to meet the aggressive filming schedule.
Instead, we were given directors’ chairs and headsets, and positioned right behind the director, as we watched the monitors that displayed what each camera was capturing.
Then one of the actors found her lines in a scene not true to whom she thought her character was. The director, listening to her concerns, cast his eyes about and asked, “Where are the writers? They need to change the lines.” Just like that, Robin and I found ourselves offering suggested changes to the script. (The director didn’t always remember we weren’t really the writers of the script. He just knew he had writers of some sort on set.)
Much to our surprise, when the climactic scene was filmed, Robin and I both cried–as if we had no idea what the scene contained. In actuality, we were overcome to see that powerful moment come to life before our very eyes. It’s one thing to read (or write) a novel. It’s another to see actors take words written by the author and make them their own.
Maybe This Isn’t Such a Bad Gig After All…
So, yeah, the road to a film is long, arduous. And full of moments when the author needs to let her creative work fly away to a land the writer never envisioned. But the joy of watching a book turn into a movie is unparalleled.
What books do you wish to see made into a movie or TV series? As a writer, do you think you could hold your creative work loosely enough to see others transform it into what they envision? What do you wonder most about how the book-into-a-movie works?
Featured Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay


I’ve written three novels; two are available on Kindle, the third, I haven’t gotten there yet.
I would hate to see any of these turned into film. They weren’t written for that, and every bit of subtlety I tried to include would be lost.
Then you know, out of the gate, that no film will done based on your work. It’s good to have clarity; so few things in life provide that.